A draft Supreme Court decision leaked this week confirmed what many have feared for months: Conservative-led courts are preparing to overthrow Rowe Wade and lose tens of millions of women to lose overnight abortion.
The 98-page Draft, certified by Chief Justice John Roberts as legitimate but not definitive, was written by Judge Samuel Alito, one of the most conservative lawyers on the jury. Here are some of the more confusing excerpts in the leaked text.
He is obsessed with keeping women in the past.
Alito repeatedly argued during the project that it was a mistake against Rowe Wade because before the 1973 decision, banning abortion was simply America’s way.
“Until the end of the 20th century, American law did not support the constitutional right to abortion. . nobody. No provision in the state constitution recognizes this right. A few years before Roe’s move, no federal or state court recognized this right.
Alito is right: Abortion has been generally banned throughout centuries of U.S. history, when women were legally treated as second-class citizens, left medical facilities and public services and banned from owning property. . . They did not gain the right to vote until 1920, and women of color encountered barriers to voting until Congress passed the right to vote in 1965, just eight years before the court’s decision.
After the decision to help, all women in the United States gained the right to apply for a credit card without the man’s consent, seek protection from abortion, and file on-the-spot. sexual harassment. Work. Until the 1990s, some states did not recognize spousal rape as a crime.
Legal progress in female body autonomy was achieved after women struggled in the decision-making space where men had long been without them. But here is what Alito said:
“The inevitable conclusion is that the right to abortion is not deeply rooted in the country’s history and tradition,” he wrote. In contrast, the continuing tradition of prohibiting abortion was maintained by criminal punishment from the early days of customary law until 1973.
She repeatedly mentioned feminists in the 1600s, who were killed by women for “witchcraft”.
Most Americans have probably never heard of Sir Matthew Hale, an English lawyer born in 1609. But Alito mentions him ten times in his project as proof that the prohibition of abortion is an important part of the legacy of our country.
Haley wrote that if a doctor gave a “child” “medicine” for an abortion, and the woman died, it was “murder” because the medicine was “illegally given to destroy her baby”, Breath. Written in 2022 to defend the abortion ban.
No wonder Haley opposes abortion, what else Reporter Recently Dig It About Him. Her legacy included the execution of two women for “witchcraft” and for defending the couple’s rape.
Although Alito considers him a criminal mastermind of fetal abortions, Hale also advocates the death penalty for children under 14 years of age.
If in all the Medical Standards Used by Hale’s life today, we don’t know the presence of germs, the components of the medicine include the skulls of death row inmates and living worms, and doctors covering in leprosy patients to absorb blood. For most of Hale’s life, doctors had no scientific understanding of where babies came from.
Ignore the major barriers to voting for abortion.
Alito wrote throughout his draft that abortion should be a matter of state law. If people want to access it, he wrote, they just have to choose the people who support it.
“Our decision brings the issue of abortion back to these legislatures and allows women on both sides of the abortion issue to seek to influence public opinion by influencing public opinion, lobbying the legislators, voting and voting for charges, ”he wrote. An elevator. “Women have no electoral or political power”.
But the right to vote is under siege as before, with many conservatives using the myth of widespread election fraud to justify policies that make voting difficult for the working class and ethnic minorities. State legislatures have recently passed such laws – which include suppression of voter identity, early voting, and voter registration windows – the same laws that plan to ban abortion as soon as possible.
Despite these problems, the Supreme Court ruled last year that it would not affect the Suspension of electoral pressure laws.
Furthermore, the will of the voters does not always determine the composition of the highest political and legal body of our country. Alito himself was appointed to the Supreme Court by a man who became president without a popular vote. So did three of the other four judges who clearly wanted to hit Rose: Brett Cavanaugh, Amy Connie Barrett, and Neil Gorsuch.
This reflects the myths of the “fetal heartbeat”.
The latest wave of abortion bans related to the “fetal heartbeat” is not based on real science, doctors have said over the years. But Alito still repeats the myths written by these laws and calls them “factual conclusions”.
The Mississippi lawmaker found that after five or six weeks of gestational age, ‘the heart of the unborn baby starts beating,’ “Alito wrote in an excerpt.
But doctors say it’s wrong to call it a heart attack and doing so is just an attempt to manipulate people’s emotions. In the first six weeks of pregnancy, the activity of the heart in the embryo – which has not yet been called a fetus – “is not the same as what an active heart would be in an adult,” says obstetrician -gynecologist Dr. Colin McNicolas. Abortion, she told HuffPost in 2019.
“Right now, it’s only two miles that there are different layers of the heart or heart cells that can vibrate or cause some kind of movement that we use to talk about the‘ fetal heartbeat ’.
Treat pregnancy and motherhood as a big thing.
Without setbacks, Alito sums up the empty argument of the anti-abortion movement: pregnancy and motherhood are not as difficult as before.
“Attitudes toward pregnancy among unmarried women have changed dramatically; “Federal and state laws prohibit discrimination based on pregnancy, whose maternity leave is usually guaranteed by law, whose pregnancy -related health care costs are covered by insurance or government assistance,” he wrote. Alito.
It should be noted that the United States is one of six countries in the world without a national paid family vacation. The rest of the world has an average of 29 paid weeks. It is also generous to say that maternity leave is promised “often” like Only 10 states And Washington has created its own laws that pay for mandatory family leave.
Contrary to Alito’s character, pregnancy and childbirth are not free. That’s the average cost of having a baby in the U.S. Nearly $ 11,000 – and that’s without complications. Accounting for antenatal and postnatal care can raise the tax to $ 30,000. Although these costs are quite different in each state.
He argues that this will make Americans more divided.
Alito also focused on how divided the country is.
“Rowe was very wrong in the beginning,” Alito wrote. “His reasoning was particularly weak and the decision had bad consequences. Far from being a national solution to the issue of abortion, that and Casey ignited the debate and deepened the rift.
But a large poll shows that there has been a much stronger public opinion on abortion over the past few decades. While many Americans favor certain restrictions on who can have an abortion and when, 6 out of 10 Americans now oppose Roy’s coup. Young people are also more in favor of access to abortion, according to surveys, suggesting that support for following the procedure may increase over time.
Source: Huffpost
