Washington (AP) – John Roberts goes to Supreme Court CEO In crisis.
“It was a time when the court was under siege, both externally and internally now,” said Todd Peppers, a Roanoke College professor who writes about the court. “I just don’t think the court’s focus has become clearer in recent history.”
Adding three conservative judges during the Trump presidency also means that there are now five conservative judges to Roberts ’right who no longer need his vote and perhaps his moderate influence to win the case. The abortion decision could be another example of this when other conservatives in court are willing to go beyond Roberts.
Roberts, 67, has exceeded the boundaries of his position in the past. Asked on a visit in 2018 How strange the head was, Roberts replied: “It’s very different. Above all, no. I have a voice. I participate in the court’s decision-making process like any fellow judge”.
However, there is a reason why the ruler is called “first of equals” and historians refer to court periods using the name of the chief judge: Marshall Court, Renquist Court, Roberts Court. The leader will be the first to speak when judges hear cases in a private conference and preside over the hearing. The employer will decide who will write the court opinion when the employer is in the majority.
Early in his career, S. Georgetown Law School Graduation Speech Elsewhere, Roberts explained his philosophy of court leadership and his superiority in decision -making, where there could be broad consensus on a narrow basis. .
“There are clear advantages to a higher level of court consensus.” Unity, or more so, contributes to the clarity and leadership of lawyers and lower courts in trying to figure out what the Court means. Supreme, ”he said in 2006. He added:“ The rule of law is strengthened when ‘there is more coherence and agreement in what we are talking about. The law is. “
Artemus Ward, a professor at the University of Northern Illinois and one of the editors of The Chief Justice Scientific Research Book, said Roberts was “trying to reach a consensus, trying to have a narrow government.” But then Death of Judge Ruth Bader GinsburgLiberal and her deputy Conservative judge Amy Connie Barrett “Roberts’s voice isn’t as loud because there are five conservative voices he doesn’t have,” Rose said.
There is already some evidence of this influence.
“Roberts has lost control of the Supreme Court,” was the title of an article written that month by Stephen I., a professor at the University of Texas School of Law. Vladek.
It is also not known how the final conclusion in the abortion case will affect the leaked draft, which was written by Judge Samuel Alito and distributed to other members of the court in February. Politico reported that Alyto had the votes of four other Conservatives to overthrow Roe Wade and a subsequent decision reaffirming the constitutional right to abortion services, Planned Parenthood v. Casey. The three liberals had plans to disagree, Politico said, while Roberts’ final vote was unclear.
Source: Huffpost
